Skip to main content

Pandemics, Extraordinary Situations and Disasters. The Voices of Ethics, Law, and Psychoanalysis

March-May 2021

Scientific Coordinators: Agar Brugiavini, Ca’ Foscari University of Venice & Venice International University (VIU); Giovanni Leonetti, Tor Vergata University of Rome; Fabrizio Turoldo, Ca' Foscari University of Venice

 

The series of webinars tackles the theme of pandemics and, more generally, that of disasters and extraordinary situations from three points of view: that of ethics, law and psychoanalysis.
It will discuss how culture processes epidemic events, how infectious calamities are perceived by society and how societies react to epidemics.
Extreme situations often force rationing medical resources, so that ethics and law are called upon to reflect on issues of justice.
This problem has recently arisen, sometimes dramatically, during the COVID-19 pandemic. There have been cases in which pulmonary ventilators were not sufficient for everyone and doctors were sometimes forced to make a patient selection. The ethics committees of various countries have produced numerous documents in which selection criteria have been proposed. Similarly, scientific societies have proposed guidelines for doctors. Some of these criteria have raised wide debates and polemics in public opinion. One of the most discussed, for example, was the age criterion.
The Webinars will explore the debate on these topics, with the help of qualified speakers, who have been protagonists of the intellectual debate on these issues.

 

Speakers:

  • Antonio Da Re, full professor of moral philosophy and bioethics at the University of Padua, member of the Italian National Committee for Bioethics;
  • Emilio Mordini, research fellow of the Health and Risk Communication Centre of the University of Haifa (Israel), Psychoanalyst. He was scientific secretary of the CNR Bioethics Commission, General Secretary of the European Association of Medical Ethics Centres (EACME);
  • Andrea Nicolussi, full professor of private law and coordinator of the Doctoral School "Person and legal systems" at the Catholic University of Milan, member of the Italian National Committee for Bioethics;
  • Mario Picozzi, physician, professor of forensic medicine and Director of the Research Centre in Clinical Ethics at the University of Insubria (Varese);
  • Stefano Semplici, full professor of Social Ethics at Rome Tor Vergata, Past Chair of the Committee for Bioethics of the Italian Society of Paediatrics. He was the Chair of the International Bioethics Committee of UNESCO from 2011 to 2015;
  • Paolo Severgnini, professor of anesthesiology, Department of Anesthesia and Critical Care, ASST dei Settelaghi, Macchi Foundation; Biotechnology and Life Sciences Department, University of Insubria (Varese).

 

Programme:

  1. Collective imaginary on epidemics  | Emilio Mordini
    Friday, 19 March 2021, 3 pm (CET)

    Confronted with crises, social groups and communities tend to show regressive psychological phenomena, which are defences against situations perceived as dangerous and threatening. They become evident in some dysfunctional behaviors (e.g. vaccine hesitancy), in urban legends, in successful narratives and can become prevalent in health communication, notably when emotional components arise, as it can happen with online communication. We call “collective symbolic coping” the sensemaking processes by which social groups interpret new or unexpected events, like an infectious outbreak. This is accomplished via the communication that arises around the event, through conversations between individuals, mass media and the Internet. In these processes, representations of the event are constructed and diffused, often appealing to collective patterns of images and thought.

    Registration closed.


  2. The Relationship Between Doctors’ Responsibilities and Guidelines in Extraordinary Situations. Ethical and Legal Issues | Antonio Da Re – Andrea Nicolussi
    Friday, 9 April 2021, 3 pm (CET)

    The current pandemic has arrived unexpectedly and has quickly reached very high peaks in spread. The situation was tragic in many respects. In some particularly affected areas, patients who needed treatment in intensive care were superior to available places and there were no clear guidelines indicating uniform criteria for patient selection. At the same time, various recommendations were proposed, which could lead to confusion; among them, the clinical ethics recommendations developed by the Italian Society of Anaesthesia, Analgesia, Resuscitation and Intensive Care (SIAARTI) have ignited a heated debate and encouraged the publication of similar documents in many other countries. This webinar deals with the most relevant ones, although the main focus is put on the Italian document, since it can be considered the guideline model, imitated in other recommendations, which provides for a limit on access to intensive care based on the a priori age criterion. Such a criterion raises issues not only about its ethical legitimacy, but also about the competence of a scientific society in providing rules that may seriously breach fundamental rights.

    Registration closed.


  3. To Look People in the Eye: Between Discretion and Arbitrariness. Clinical Ethics at the Test of Pandemics | Mario Picozzi – Paolo Severgnini
    Friday, 23 April 2021, 3 pm (CET)


    The Coronavirus pandemic has deeply marked all ordinary healthcare activities and has dictated matters usually faced by the medicine of disasters. The most critical and dramatic dilemma has been the triage and the urge to select patients for Intensive Care Unit, since there was no place for all at the same time. The need to decide, in a very short time, has made this decision even more complex. Data of the Italian situation (especially in Lombardia) reveal it clearly. Worldwide, there have been many different views on triage, sometimes with very peculiar emphasis. During the webinar, Prof. Picozzi and Prof. Severgnini will illustrate the contributions of the Unites States compared to the European ones, stressing several shared elements, such as clinical criteria, notwithstanding the differences. There is, in fact, a huge gap between the US view and the European one in the appointment of the final decision maker in triage. The speakers propose the criterion of proportionality as a guide line for this kind of decisions, since it allows to integrate collective public health objectives with the principle of ensuring protection of the individual patient. The potential role of ethics consultation in this pandemic scenario is also envisaged.

    Registration closed.


  4. The Philosophical Debate on the Age Criterion for the Selection of Patients | Stefano Semplici
    Friday, 14 May 2021, 3 pm (CET)

    Covid-19 has highlighted, from a dual point of view, the vulnerability of the elderly. It was immediately clear that, for them, the risk of serious consequences and death was much greater. Furthermore, when ventilators were not enough for all those in need, the different documents produced by committees and scientific societies in the Western world could not avoid taking a position on the age criterion for the selection of patients. In this debate, two parties were opposed: those who claim that the achievement of the greatest good for the greatest number implies the recognition of the age criterion as an ethical, objective and cost-effective one for the allocation of resources, and those who dispute it, with strong arguments, based precisely on equity and rights and for which age-based rationing is just an example of discrimination against older people, an example of ageism. How to interpret this seemingly unyielding contrast?

    Registration closed.

 

Who can participate?

Students (graduates, undergraduates, PhDs), professors, VIU Community members, and the general public.

 

Registration:

Registration via VIU website is required.

 

For further information: ageing@univiu.org

 

 

Student Guide 2st semester 2020-2021

Download here the Student Guide for the 2nd semester 2020-2021

It is an ePub file and can be opened with most readers on mobile devices, and also on Macs and Pcs.

Suggested apps 

macOS
Apple Books
Calibre

iOS
Apple Books
Marvin 3

Windows
Freda
Calibre

Android
Google Play Books
Moon+ Reader
Universal Book Reader
FBreader

You can also use the browser extension:
-EPUBReader for Chrome and Firefox
-Readium for Chrome

You should be able to download one of these options from your usual app store.
If you have any problems opening the file please ask for assistance at student-services@univiu.org 

2nd Semester of AY 2021-22 Courses

Orientation week                     February 14-18
Opening Ceremony      February 17
Courses begin February 21
Midterm exam week April 4-8
Midterm break April 18-22
Courses end May 20
Exam week May 23-27
Closing Ceremony May 26
   
National holidays April 18, April 25, May 1

 

*Link to course descriptions on each course title

 

Italy

History of Venice
Luca Pes, Venice International University
S2201

 

Italian Contemporary History in Films
Luca Pes, Venice International University
S2202

 

Italian for Foreigners - beginner, intermediate, upper intermediate
Massimo Brunzin (coordinator), Venice International University
S2203

 

Art and Architecture in Renaissance Venice
Fabrizio Nevola, University of Exeter
S2204


Cultures of the World

Intercultural Communication
Marcel Burger, Université de Lausanne
S2205

 

Gender Studies: Gender, Sexuality and Society
Tania Hossain, Waseda University
S2206

 

Comparing East and West. Legal and Political Systems and Thinking in a Globalized World
Danny Pieters, Bert Demarsin and Gerard Everaet, KU Leuven
S2207


Global Challenges

Identity, Heritage and Globalization. Culture, Heritage and Globalization in the Context of Indian Society
Tania Hossain, Waseda University
S2208

 

Globalization, Ethics, Welfare and Human Rights: Sustainable Social Protection in a Globalized World
Danny Pieters, Paul Schoukens and Gerard Everaet, KU Leuven
S2209

 

Global Governance for Peace and Security, Cooperation and Development (online)
Hans-Martin Schönherr-Mann, Ludwig Maximilians Universität
S2210


Specialization Track: Environmental Management and Sustainable Development

Globalization, Environment and Sustainable Development
Ilda Mannino, Venice International University
S2211

 

Disability and Sustainable Design
Mark Olson, Duke University
S2212

 

Climate Data Analysis and Forecasting (online)
Byeongseon Seo, Korea University
S2214

 

Fashion Futuring
Alessandra Vaccari, Università Iuav di Venezia
S2215

 

Economics of Piracy
Yulia Vymyatnina and Mikhail Pakhnin, European University at St. Petersburg
S2216

 

Natural Resource Economics and Sustainable Development
Yulia Vymyatnina and Mikhail Pakhnin, European University at St. Petersburg
S2217

 

Food Safety
Klemen Bohinc, University of Ljubljana
S2218

 

Cities and Global Change

Public Renaissance: Urban Cultures of Public Space between Early Modern Europe and the Present
Fabrizio Nevola, University of Exeter
S2219

 

Urban Quality of Life in Global Perspective
Marc Landy, Boston College
S2220

 

Single Life and Friendships in the Global City
Kinneret Lahad, Tel Aviv University
S2221

 

Gendered Families in the Global City
Kinneret Lahad, Tel Aviv University
S2222

 

Physics of Cities and Society
Klemen Bohinc, University of Ljubljana
S2223

 

Theories of Urban Space and Sense of Place in Global Change
Maria Chiara Tosi and Claudia Faraone, Università Iuav di Venezia
S2224

 

Cities and Global Change: Urban Policy Analysis and Design
Matteo Basso, Università Iuav di Venezia Regional Planning
S2225

 


Environmental Humanities

Public Spaces, Citizenship and Environment in the Digital Age
Marcel Burger, Université de Lausanne
S2226

 

Imperiled Cities In Comparative Perspective
Marc Landy, Boston College
S2227

 

Ecology and Technology as Global Challenges of Ethics (online)
Hans-Martin Schönherr-Mann, Ludwig Maximilians Universität
S2228

 

Eco Media
Mark Olson, Duke University
S2229

 

Rights of Nature and Animal Rights: an Ecocentric Legal Approach
Sara De Vido, Università Ca’ Foscari Venezia
S2230

 

 

1st Semester of AY 2021-22 Courses

 Orientation week  September 6-10
 Opening Ceremony  September 9
 Courses begin  September 13
 Midterm break  November 1-5
 Courses end  December 10
 Exam week  December 13-17
 Closing Ceremony  December 16

 

 

*Link to course descriptions on each course title

Italy

History of Venice
Luca Pes, Venice International University
F2101

Italian Contemporary History in Films
Luca Pes, Venice International University
F2102

Italian for Foreigners - beginner, intermediate, upper intermediate
Massimo Brunzin (coordinator), Venice International University
F2103

Art and Architecture in Renaissance Venice
Paola Modesti, Venice International University
F2104


Cultures of the World

Intercultural Communication
Sabrina Marchetti and Dany Carnassale, Università Ca' Foscari Venezia
F2105

Gender Studies: Gender and Politics
Martina Avanza, Université de Lausanne
F2106

Comparing East and West. Heroines in International Films
Lisa Cuklanz, Boston College
F2107

Global Challenges

Identity, Heritage and Globalization. Biennale Venezia 2021 - The Anthropology of Built Environment and Social Space
Natalie Göltenboth, Ludwig Maximilians Universität
F2108

Globalization, Ethics, Welfare and Human Rights. 
Aleksandar Kešeljevic, University of Ljubljana
F2109

Global Governance for Peace and Security, Cooperation and Development
Paolo Roberto Graziano, Pietro De Perini and Igor Guardiancich, Università degli Studi di Padova
F2110

Specialization Track: Economics, Management and Digital Technologies Applied to Cultural Heritage 

Economics and Management of (Art and) Culture
Aleksandar Kešeljevic, University of Ljubljana
F2112

Digital Technology and Cultural Heritage
Alison Harcourt, University of Exeter
F2113

Venice Strikes Back: Antitourism Mobilizations in the Serenissima
Martina Avanza, Université de Lausanne
F2114

Urban History and Digital Tools: The Advent of the Modern Capital City and Venice
Cristiano Guarneri and Gianmario Guidarelli, Università Ca' Foscari Venezia/ Università di Padova
F2120

 Science and Society  

Global Internet Governance
Alison Harcourt, University of Exeter
F2115

Science Communication and Sustainability 
Ilda Mannino and Alessandra Fornetti, Venice International University
F2116

Science (Fiction) and Posthuman
Edward Chan, Waseda University
F2117

History and Memory

Anthropological Perspectives on Borders, Migration and Mobility in the Mediterranean 
Natalie Göltenboth, Ludwig Maximilians Universität
F2118

Italian Immigration Film
Lisa Cuklanz, Boston College
F2119

History and Memory at the Intercultural Crossroads
Edward Chan, Waseda University
F2121

Memory Study, an Introduction
Julia Safronova, European University at St. Petersburg
F2122

Memory and Media: between Pyramids and the Internet
Julia Safronova, European University at St. Petersburg
F2123

Representations of Time and Space in Western and Far Eastern Cultures
Agostino De Rosa, Iuav University of Venice
F2124

Mosaics on the Adriatic Shore: History in Transition
Assaf Pinkus, Tel Aviv University
F2125

Gothic Tales: Creation and Reception of Visual Historical Myths
Assaf Pinkus, Tel Aviv University
F2126